The barefoot debate
Monday, 22 March 2010
/site/_content/image/00003088-image.jpg

You’re used to coming to our website for the facts.

But whether or not barefoot running is good for you is hotly contested topic and running preferences is a much more subjective matter.

Welcome to the first debate where we give you the facts, but you give us the answers.

Is barefoot running better for you?
It’s no coincidence that the vast majority of people run with shoes on; shoes are both practical and safe.

They stop your feel getting dirty or uncomfortable and guard against the cuts and bruises your feet might receive as they pound various paths, roads, beaches and trails.

However, by consistently wearing shoes, we deny ourselves the proper chance to develop the muscles in our feet and legs that would otherwise develop in order to soften our stride.

There are arguments for both sides of the debate.

Arguments for running with shoes
Advancements in technology have enabled us to come up with shoes that better suit different types of feet.

Extra cushioning helps soften the impact of some of the harder surfaces such as roads and footpaths.

Shoes will also help you avoid dangers such as stepping on glass or other sharp objects.

Arguments for running barefoot
By running barefoot you will strengthen the muscles of the feet and legs.

Your body will learn how to run in a more efficient way, reducing the amount of shock created from each footfall.

Calluses will develop that will allow you to run or harder surfaces.

You will save money on shoes.

To digress
Before shoes were worn or invented humans were able to live comfortably without shoes.

With the proper training, our feet could also develop the proper calluses to run comfortably barefoot.

With modern lifestyles, although most runners’ foot muscles are under-developed, by putting shoes on we partially eliminate the need to ever develop the foot muscles in the first place.

The real debate seems to be whether or not our joints and bones will absorb less shock by wearing shoes (due to the cushioning effects that shoes provide) or by running barefoot (due to training adaptions the feet and the legs would make in response to a barefoot running routine).

Certainly more conventional thinking would point towards wearing shoes. The harder surfaces of today (roads and footpaths) would make it tougher on the feet to run barefoot today than it would have been centuries ago.

But at what point do advancements in out footwear start to detrain our feet and will that ultimately be to our disadvantage?

Interesting perspectives
The three websites below both discuss the barefoot debate, with some discussion from opposing sides.

Barefoot Ken Bob (in support of barefoot running).

Ross Tucker's blog (Offers, at length, a detailed analysis of the debate).

Brooks running(in support of running with shoes).

Feel free to leave your thoughts and comments below along with your first name. We’d love to hear them and share them in this discussion.

 
Comments
Posted by Laura at 08/04/2010 12:14 PM
I've never seriously tried barefoot running, though i want to. I definitely see how it develops foot and leg muscles and seems may improve biomechanical efficiency. But i think one problem is the possibility of stepping on sharp objects (calluses can't completely protect). also, we're not designed to run on hard surfaces like concrete and asphalt so maybe because of the impact it's best not to run barefoot on them. however it's also not natural to wear shoes, and every different technical feature in shoes is something that humans have evolved without. Just thinking about my dog, domesticated animals run around on hard surfaces in bare feet/paws and don't seem to have any problems (but no, its not quite the same). I think the best places for barefoot running are grass and sand except for the risk of stepping on dangerous things, and stick to the shoes for pavement - shoes and bare feet in moderation. oh, and saving on shoes is always a plus!!!
Posted by col clacy at 13/04/2010 08:51 PM
i agree with both sides. so i walk for 20-30 minutes/day barefoot then don my ascics and go out for another 30-45 minutes. to train my feet i use aqua shoes($9 in big w)on w/ends and as much as possible. cheers, col.
Posted by Rob Brown at 16/04/2010 12:21 PM
I have been running in Crocs for over a year now to simulate running in bare feet but without the problems of glass and stones and getting cut feet. I have found that my foot, ankle and lower leg muscles, especially my calves, get a really good workout and so every fourth or so run I wear running shoes. I find this gives these muscles a rest and reduces risk of injury. The great thing I've found about running in Crocs is that the more challenging the terrain (i.e. variable) the better. The whole foot, including the toes, adjust with each step to achhieve the best and most comfortable landing position. This puts much less stress on the ankles. I have yet to do a race in Crocs but, given some of my training times I reckon I could achieve a PB using them. The key is to start barefoot or Croc running slowly to allow these previously largely unused muscles to build their strength. Running in Crocs is a lot of fun and they are so light!
Posted by Michele at 16/04/2010 02:25 PM
I am a believer in the barefoot ruuning.I often do my running in a pair of Vibrams 5 fingers. Shoes that fit like gloves. There is no support or cushinging. This allows your feet to feel the ground and be protected at the same time.I mostly use them on my slow recovery runs 3 times a week.I believe they do stenghten not only your feet but legs as well. I think the shoes they are making now have to much support and cushioning and don't allow in to use any of the muscules in your feet.But every one is different.
Posted by Sharon at 17/04/2010 07:42 AM
Many people in the world manage barefoot, I got a pair of feelmax shoes from USA, when I run in them I feel different, my foot lands differently and I seem to use my knees more for cushioning. I also don't stress so much on what I may stand on, you feel the big stones, but not so much worry about glass and so on. I am still not sure which is best but do enjoy my nearly barefootrunning , however I am a girl that goes shoeless as much as possible around home. When I run in shoes my feet feel heavy and cramped hot, and my first thought upon finishing is get the shoes off, maybe I need more barefooot running in my life.
Posted by Emma Lucas at 22/04/2010 10:03 PM
In order to run more efficiently and cause less injuries you don't necessarily have to go without shoes. You can train to run using the barefoot techniques while wearing shoes, just watch the evolution running videos on Youtube. It's all about training yourself to land on your forefoot rather than heel striking. Of course if you don't wear shoes it forces you to land on your forefoot, when wearing shoes you actually have to think about what you are doing.
Submit a comment
Name
Email
Comment

This calculator uses one of your recent race times to reveal what pace you should run. Click here

 
How much does your running depend on the weather?



Great runs
PC
More Screensavers